Sunday, April 18, 2010

Chocolate Chip Oreo Cookies







I procrastinate from my homework the best when I'm baking. Seriously. Instead of writing a 1000 word paper, I browse through my bookmarks on my computer and decide what I want to bake. After figuring out my next culinary mission, I get right to it and start mixing my little heart away. Once everything is set and cooled, I figure, "Well... I already have all my materials out, why not bake something else?" This is where the process starts all over again; It's like a never-ending circle of baking that will, in turn, doom my academic career.

Were these cookies worth it? Totally. The concept of a cookie in a cookie is just genius. Kind of like cookie dough in cookie dough. Wait, what? Is that even possible? Anyways, I made these cookies into little itty-bitty baby ones because I wanted bite sized treats. That resulted in me eating a million cookies instead of one. Oops. They're full of flavor (taste just like cookies n' cream ice cream, really) and the oreo texture in it is wonderful! They're also chewy, not crumbly. I subbed baking powder for baking soda because I didn't have any on hand, which is why my cookies are a bit puffy than normal. That actually works even better for mini cookies! Adapted from Picky Palate.

  • 1 stick softened butter
  • 6 Tablespoons sugar
  • 6 Tablespoons brown sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 1 ¼ cup flour
  • ½ teaspoon baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 11 broken pieces Oreo Cookies
  • 1 cup chocolate chips

1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Cream butter, and sugars until well combined. Add egg and vanilla until mixed well.

2. Place flour, baking soda and salt into a large bowl, stir to combine. Slowly add dry ingredients to wet ingredients then stir in oreos and chocolate chips until just combined.

3. With a medium cookie scoop, scoop onto baking sheet. Bake for 10 minutes or until cooked, but still soft. Let cool on baking sheet for 3 minutes before transferring to cooling rack.



Ask me anything on Formspring

62 comments:

motioncityerinn said...

that sounds like only the most awesome idea ever. I'm so excited. Those also look absolutely amazing

nicole said...

omg! please email me any info you have as far as where to send payments to!

email:
cakielicious@gmail.com

Memória said...

These cookies look great. In the first shot, I thought it was ice cream! :)

Rachelle @ "Mommy? I'm Hungry!" said...

Oh yUm! These sounds amazing, I'm going to have to mark these to make, unless the oreos get eaten first!

I love the idea of a cookie mailing list! I'd love to know more about it. I'll email ya!

Sharlene said...

I'm the same way! These days I have definitive spurts. Yesterday, for example, I made lemon curd, blueberry cupcakes with lemon zest, and then whipped together some pizza dough on top of making dinner for myself. I spend my "days" of research looking up recipes for later. It's terrible and my lovehandles hate it! I love the idea of a cookie mailing. I wish this poor med student could afford it! Btw these cookies look genius.

Sandy said...

Those sound delicious! Totally making those as soon as my cookie jar is empty!! Thanks!

Sarah B @ Bake + Bike said...

Cookie-within-a-cookie! I love it!

I'm rather sad I can't partake in your cookie mailing list (I live in Canada). If you ever start shipping to your northern neighbours, I would be suuuuper excited!! I totally understand why it's not that practical, though.

Joanne said...

You and I are so alike it's crazy. I swear, the day before an exam, I always feel the need to bake both a loaf of bread and a cake. It's insane. And will lead to my demise. But eh, what can you do.

Your idea to start a cookie mailing list is awesome! What a great way to make money. If you're going to be bakign anyway, might as well!

These cookies are amazing!

Cindy said...

Mmm! Yum! These look great! Cute blog!

aforaubergine.com said...

OMG! These look stellar! I just found your blog and you've won me over. :)

Avalee said...

These cookies look fantastic (I especially like that you took a bite out of one for a picture!) I'm putting the recipe on my list of things-to-try :-)

nnitro said...

Hahaha this cracked me up! I have been won over as well.

And I have to make those cookies. HAVE. TO. TODAY.

Cookie said...

I just happened to have some Oreos at home! Gonna make these real soon!

hannah! said...

nothing beats oreos. wait, these have done it!

Shannon @ bakeandbloom said...

Does anyone else think this is kind of cookie cannabalisim? Making cookies from cookies.

They look seriously yummy though

Kristina said...

Long time reader, first time commenter. I love your blog and I'm pretty sure I've bookmarked just about every recipe you've posted. PS I remember in a post a while back you said you visited a friend at BYU. Well I went there too! So, yay.
Ok, I am making these tonight! I can't wait to try them! And I like how puffy yours are so I'm going to do the powder for soda sub as well. Thanks for this recipe!

chelsea rebecca said...

i was just introduced to your blog and all i can say is OH. MY. GOODNESS. i've shamelessly went through your posts all the way back to januaray! haha. and it took everything i had not to skip class and make these oreo cookies! i absolutely love all your recipes and i cannot wait to try them out!!

Smart CoOKie said...

I just made those cookies and they are so yummy. Thank you for the recipe. =]

Arlene said...

Oh I would love to know more about the cookie mailing! That sounds great.

My email is: angellover54@hotmail.com

52kitchenadventures said...

A cookie within a cookie?! Genius! Now I'm thinking of all the possibilities...I see some baking in my near future.
-Stephanie

Shanon said...

great idea! I hope you keep doing the cookie mailing list. I would like to buy a few months worth for a friend's birthday. But her birthday isn't until August!

your cookies all look amazing! i have bookmarked tons!

neeciechan said...

I remember asking you over FB a while back if you were doing your mailing list ever again, I gotta say.. as soon as I realized you were doing it again, I was effing STOKED!! I use a lot of your recipes and so you have no idea how amazing it is that I have a chance to eat them, baked by the infamous baker queen hahaha.

I don't know how you would like to set up payments, if I should send out some $$ every month or if there's a way to just automate it haha, or if you prefer it all in advance, just let me know! <333

neeciechan said...

also, before I forget, my email is
dewlettizzle@hotmail.com

Get back to me whenever is convenient :]

Patti said...

Isn't procrastinating by baking the BEST THING ever?! I do the exact same thing. Anyway, when I get home from the library tonight, I'm totally making these. But with Tagalongs, since I don't have any Oreos in the hizouse. Thanks for the inspiration. :)

Chef Dennis said...

you are amazing....the whole show should have just been about you, and Martha should have flown you out on her jet

What's Cooking Kristen said...

I just made these and they are AMAZINGGG!!! Thanks for sharing :)

Melanie said...

I stumbled upon your blog doing a google search for brownies and I can't wait to look around!

zoom yummy said...

Mmmm, that looks wonderful. Could you send some over, please? :)

Cheers!

Petra

Meg said...

This recipe rocks! I visited my friend at Penn State this weekend and made these for her! I used Newmans Own Mint Oreos instead of normal ones.. made these awesome cookies incredible! They were a hit!

Marie said...

I made this today. It tasted really good. I love the Oreos. But mine turned out flat. My oven decided to be stupid today and the temp was much lower than it should be. It was still good though.

Noemi said...

These look sooooo good. I love oreos. I'm definitely going to bake these soon!

Joshua Miller said...

I made these for mother's day and everybody really liked them. Thanks for the recipe <3.

Anonymous said...

The cookies look awesome! Hmm, what do you mean by a medium-sized scoop? A teaspoon?

Amanda said...

Made these so many times already I've practically got it memorized!! ;) I have two little brothers who have been so happy with this amazing recipe. Thank You So Much!!

Jess :) said...

I just discovered your blog on foodgawker. Love it!

Question: How many grams is one stick of butter? I never know! I want to make these cookies next weekend. :)

Mandy said...

I stumbled upon your blog, found this recipe, and immediately made these cookies.... but with a twist. I used peanut butter oreos and added about 2 tablespoons of creamy peanut butter! Awesome! Thanks for the recipe :)

corbie said...

just made these with your baking powder and small cookie changes and they turned out great! a nice yummy "choco chip" cookie with a twist :D

Merlot said...

Just made these and they are amazing!!! thanks for the recipe!

Ariel said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
soupusurper said...

Made these last night...wow! So easy, so good, perfect level of chewiness, even on the second day! Something a little more special than your average chocolate chip. Thank you!

Ellen said...

I made these today and i'm eating one now. they are DELICIOUS. mine didn't look like the picture but they taste just fine. thanks!

nicole said...

Oh I love Oreos! I love them in everything. I would get in trouble if I made this cookie. ButI might have to anyway :-)

deadbored17 said...

Hey, i'm from nz, and we don't have sticks of butter here.. how many grams is a stick of butter?

Michael said...

I made these last night and they came out great! And they're even better cold out of the fridge on day 2!

katieallover said...

First off, I would like to say how similar we are that we both procrastinate so much when we think up recipes. I do this all the time when I just can't pay attention in biology. Second, your blog is beautiful and the pictures you take are absolutely perfect. And third, I used this recipe on my blog but instead of using chocolate chips, I substituted white chocolate chips and I added oreo instant pudding mix to the batter and my best friend and boyfriend swear by those cookies. Thank you for the inspiration and such a great recipe!!!

Pammi's Kitchen said...

I finally got around to trying these cookies this past weekend and we loved them they are gorgeous.

Not good at all for my diet!

2f5d2b08-bee0-11e0-9e8d-000bcdcb5194 said...

I made these today. I expected the cookies to be dark like your pictures. Unfortunately they looked like normal chocolate chip cookies. The only difference was that they had Oreo pieces inside of them. How did you make yours dark? I followed the recipe and crushed 11 Oreos into small pieces.

Stephanie said...

I just made these for my husband to take to a potluck at work. They are delicious! :)

mabel said...

these look absolutely diviiiine :D
oreos inside another cookie, brilliant!

Isabella said...

Yum, my brother (chocolate addict) would LOVE this.
Hey can you guys have a quick look at my blog, it's ok if you don't like it but it's a bit like this. I would REALLY appreciate it. Here's the address
http://dandelionamazingblog.blogspot.com/

Mrs. AA said...

I am a terrible cook, baker, even take-out orderer... But you have some recipes I will definitely try. And hopefully not mangle beyond recognition. Awesome site!

Lily said...

Oh these sound like ice cream in cookie form :)

jacqueline said...

tried it, loved it, thanks!

Anonymous said...

For some reason my cookies turned out like pancakes and were stuck to the pan; the pan is in the trash. :( no cookies for my hubby and I! :(

Mind Over Matter said...

They didn't turn out small and white colored like yours did. But i still think they tasted good.


I wonder why they didn't turn out like yours. PRACTICE MAKES PERFECT.

Amanda B said...

These were THE greatest cookies I have ever baked. My first round of cookies were too dark so I only put them in for 7 minutes instead of 10 (It is probably because of my oven).

Free India Classifieds said...

Really nice recipe thanks

Anonymous said...

Would it work to use white chocolate chips instead?? I wonder.....

Anonymous said...

Just finished baking these, so delicious! I tried another recipe before and they came out kind of dry.. these are perfect! My stomach is full and happy :) Thank you for sharing!

Brhea {NoPlaceLykeHome} said...

Great recipe! I just made them today and posted about them on my blog :) Thanks so much for sharing.

So happy to have found your blog!

Danielle said...

All I have to say is 'WOW' but not solely because of the recipe, but because of your first sentence I procrastinate from my homework the best when I'm baking.' This is 100% me I do exactly the same thing! My love for baking began because of my hate for writing papers. I now find baking relaxing and whenever I'm stress I turn to my bookmarks. Thanks for adding one to my list! Happy Procrastination Baking!

freewebcoach.org said...

I would really like to take a bite on one of these...